New Delhi: The petition highlights the economic impact of demonstrations, rallies and shutdown calls on commercial establishments, particularly in areas such as Connaught Place and other prominent business districts. Appearing for the traders, senior advocate Mukul Rohatgi told the court that protests and rallies had allegedly caused business losses estimated at nearly Rs 2,000 crore.
Rohatgi argued that the existing approach to designating protest sites needed reconsideration in view of the changing circumstances and the growing population of Central Delhi. He pointed out that Ramlila Maidan is located approximately a mile from Connaught Place and that the surrounding area includes hospitals and residential neighbourhoods inhabited by nearly 50 lakh people.
Representing various traders’ associations across Delhi, Rohatgi said commercial activity had suffered considerably, with shops remaining shut and business districts witnessing a sharp decline in footfall. He stressed that the festive season was particularly important for retailers, and any disruption during this period could have serious financial consequences.
“We have moved considerably beyond the circumstances in which Jantar Mantar and Ramlila Maidan were originally designated as protest venues. We need to think of a different arrangement,” Rohatgi submitted, urging the court to explore a practical solution that balances the right to protest with the interests of businesses and residents.
He sought a blanket restriction on protests and sit-ins in the affected areas for the next two months, arguing that traders could no longer sustain the losses caused by repeated disruptions.
Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, appearing for the Centre, submitted that organisations calling for shutdowns must also be held accountable for the consequences. He also informed the court that permission granted to the CJP (Citizens for Justice and Peace) for a protest was limited to one day, but the demonstrators allegedly occupied the designated site for 17 days and subsequently marched towards Parliament.
Mehta maintained that protesters could not proceed towards Parliament or the Supreme Court without the requisite authorisation.
However, the bench emphasised that the organisers of the demonstrations must be made parties to the proceedings before any decision is taken. Chief Justice of India Justice Surya Kant observed that the court could not pass an order affecting protesters without first hearing their position.
The CJI also stressed that authorities granting or refusing permission for demonstrations must record clear reasons for their decisions. No group, he observed, could claim an exclusive right over a public space and prevent others from exercising their legitimate rights merely because it was holding a protest there.
The Chief Justice further underlined the need to identify protest venues in a manner that does not jeopardise the livelihoods of economically vulnerable sections.
“If shops are forced to shut because of demonstrations, where will shopkeepers and street vendors earn their livelihood?” the CJI observed, highlighting the need to protect the interests of small traders and daily earners while preserving the democratic right to dissent.
The proceedings brought into focus the competing interests of traders seeking uninterrupted commercial activity and citizens exercising their constitutional right to peaceful protest.
While the traders have sought restrictions on demonstrations during the crucial festive period, the court indicated that any decision would require hearing all stakeholders, including the organisations that organised the protests.
The Supreme Court directed the petitioners to implead the protest organisers as parties to the case, making it clear that no substantive order could be passed without giving them an opportunity to present their views.

