New Delhi: The Delhi High Court has ordered the immediate removal of six social media URLs containing allegedly defamatory AI-generated videos, images and posts depicting Delhi Chief Minister Rekha Gupta in a demeaning manner. The Court observed that political satire and humour cannot be used as a justification for attacking an individual’s dignity.
Justice Manoj Jain issued the direction on Friday while hearing a defamation suit filed by Gupta against the Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) and other parties over the alleged circulation of AI-generated and deepfake content across social media platforms.
The Court acknowledged that politicians and public officeholders are subject to intense public scrutiny, criticism and political commentary. However, it made clear that such scrutiny does not give anyone the liberty to undermine an individual’s dignity.
“Satire may though hurt the conscience of any individual, but it cannot be permitted to create an irreparable wound on someone’s dignity,” the Court observed.
Gupta had moved the High Court seeking a permanent injunction against the creation, publication and circulation of allegedly defamatory AI-generated material and deepfake content.
According to her petition, certain videos and images were allegedly shared through official and verified social media accounts of AAP. The content purportedly depicted her in different roles, including that of a liquor seller, hawker and delivery agent. It also referred to an alleged scheme titled “Har Har Rekha or Ghar Ghar Theka”.
Representing the Chief Minister, her counsel argued that the material was highly derogatory, stigmatic and damaging to her reputation, and requested its immediate removal from online platforms.
Court Flags Misuse of AI in Political Campaigns
During the hearing, the Court examined the nature of the disputed material. One of the videos allegedly depicted Gupta serving drinks to men at night amid a brawl, with a romantic soundtrack playing in the background.
Another video purportedly showed the Chief Minister and Delhi Deputy Chief Minister pouring liquor and ice cubes. The Court observed that the AI-generated visuals appeared to be a “near-perfect imitation”.
It noted that such portrayals could create a misleading impression about Gupta’s personal conduct and potentially damage her dignity and moral standing.
The Court reiterated that holding public office invites greater scrutiny, but this does not mean that an individual’s dignity can be disregarded.
It further distinguished legitimate political criticism from personal attacks, observing that political parties are free to question government policies, decisions and administrative performance in a democratic setup.
However, allegedly offensive AI-generated depictions that undermine the dignity of an individual cannot automatically claim protection in the name of political satire.
Justice Jain observed that there is a narrow distinction between humour and satire on one side and an offensive attack on someone’s dignity on the other.
The Court said that while judicial intervention may not be necessary in cases involving ordinary humour or satire, appropriate action becomes necessary when an individual’s dignity is attacked, ridiculed or tarnished.
Court Raises Concern Over Realistic AI-Generated Content
The High Court also expressed concern over the growing accessibility of artificial intelligence tools, which have made it increasingly easy to create highly realistic videos and images.
At the same time, it emphasised that responsibility for generating and publishing such material ultimately rests with the individuals involved.
Holding that Gupta had established a prima facie case, the Court found that the balance of convenience favoured her. It also noted that the rapid circulation of the disputed material on social media could cause serious and irreparable damage.
Accordingly, the Court directed defendants 3, 4 and 5 to immediately remove the six URLs identified in the petition.
The Court also issued summons to the defendants and instructed them to submit their written statements within 30 days of receiving the summons.
The matter has been scheduled for its next hearing on December 4.

