New Delhi: The Delhi High Court has overturned a Railway Claims Tribunal order that rejected compensation to the family of a passenger who died after falling from a moving train, holding that the mere fact that he was travelling on a Monthly Season Ticket (MST) did not disqualify him from being treated as a bona fide railway passenger.
The court observed that the Railways had failed to produce any specific instruction establishing that an MST holder was prohibited from travelling in the unreserved compartment of an express train. It further clarified that the absence of a separate superfast surcharge ticket could not, by itself, be treated as sufficient grounds to reject the compensation claim without first determining whether such a surcharge requirement applied to the train concerned.
Justice Manoj Kumar Ohri passed the order while allowing a petition filed by Manju Lata Verma and other family members of the deceased, Vijay Kumar Verma. The court set aside the Railway Claims Tribunal’s decision and remanded the matter for determination of the compensation payable to the family.
The High Court also directed the Tribunal to assess the compensation in accordance with law and ensure that the concerned authorities release the amount within two months of receiving a copy of the order. The matter has been listed before the Tribunal for December 1, 2026.
Background of the Case
The case relates to an incident dated August 19, 2015, when Vijay Kumar Verma was travelling from Old Delhi Railway Station towards Ghaziabad aboard the Sealdah Express.
According to the family’s plea, Verma was a regular commuter and held a valid Monthly Season Ticket covering the Meerut City–Delhi route in both directions. The MST was valid until September 12, 2015, and its validity had also been verified by the Railways.
On the day of the incident, Verma was returning from work. Since no train was available for Ghaziabad at that particular time, he boarded the Sealdah Express with the intention of reaching Ghaziabad and subsequently catching another train to Meerut.
Due to heavy overcrowding in the general compartment, he was reportedly standing near the train’s entrance. When the train reached Shahdara Railway Station, he fell from the moving train and suffered serious injuries.
He was initially admitted to GTB Hospital and later shifted to Batra Hospital, where he died on August 25, 2015, from his injuries.
Why Did the Tribunal Reject the Compensation Claim?
Manju Lata Verma had challenged the Railway Claims Tribunal’s March 22, 2017 order dismissing the family’s compensation petition.
The Tribunal had concluded that the deceased could not be considered a bona fide passenger because his MST was not valid for travelling on the Sealdah Express, which was classified as a superfast train.
However, the High Court found that the Railways had not substantiated this position by placing the relevant travel restrictions or applicable instructions on record.
Justice Ohri emphasised that the Tribunal had rejected the claim without adequately establishing whether an MST holder was actually barred from travelling in the unreserved compartment of the train in question.
Setting aside the Tribunal’s decision, the High Court directed it to reconsider the matter and determine the compensation due to the deceased passenger’s family.
The ruling underscores the importance of examining applicable railway rules and evidence before denying compensation to families of passengers who lose their lives in train accidents.
Subscribe to Updates
Get the latest creative news from FooBar about art, design and business.
Delhi High Court: MST Holder Eligible for Railway Accident Compensation, Tribunal Order Set Aside
Delhi High Court sets aside Railway Tribunal order, ruling that MST holders cannot be denied compensation without proof of travel restrictions.
Compensation for Railway Accident Victims Delhi High Court Delhi High Court Judgment Indian Judiciary Indian Railways Legal News India Monthly Season Ticket Holder MST Holder MST Passenger Rights Passenger Compensation Railway Accident Case Railway Accident Claim Railway Accident Compensation Railway Claims Tribunal Railway Claims Tribunal Order Railway Compensation Rules Railway Passenger Rights Train Accident Compensation Tribunal Order Set Aside
Related Posts
Add A Comment

