New Delhi: A court at Delhi’s Rouse Avenue on Thursday dismissed a revision petition filed by Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) MLA Karnail Singh, who had challenged the order initiating criminal defamation proceedings against him on a complaint filed by Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) leader and former Delhi minister Satyender Jain.
Special Judge Ruby Neeraj Kumar rejected Singh’s challenge after hearing arguments from both sides. The dispute relates to alleged remarks made by Singh during a television news channel interview on January 19, 2025, when he was contesting against Jain in the Delhi Assembly elections.
Jain Accuses BJP MLA of Making Defamatory Claims
Jain’s complaint alleges that Singh made several statements accusing him of corruption and accumulating wealth through unlawful means. Among the claims attributed to Singh was that the Enforcement Directorate (ED) had recovered 37 kg of gold from Jain’s residence and that the former minister owned 1,100 acres of land.
The complaint further alleges that Singh accused Jain of misusing public money, described him as a “Bhoo Mafia” and a corrupt person, and predicted that he would return to jail. Jain has maintained that these allegations were false and damaging to his reputation.
Sessions Court Had Earlier Ordered Reconsideration
The case has previously undergone a round of revision proceedings. Singh challenged the magistrate’s order before the Sessions Court, arguing that the alleged statements were based on an ED press release and media reports.
His counsel also contended that Singh, as a candidate in the Assembly elections, had a responsibility to inform voters about his political opponent, who had served as a minister. On April 30, the Sessions Court set aside the earlier cognizance order and sent the matter back to the magistrate for fresh consideration of the legal exceptions cited by Singh’s defence.
Special Judge Jitendra Singh observed that the magistrate could not defer consideration of the statutory exceptions entirely to the trial stage. The court said a limited assessment of the alleged statements, the available material and the exceptions invoked by the defence was necessary to determine whether there were sufficient grounds to proceed. The Sessions Court clarified that it had not examined the other grounds of challenge on their merits and left the relevant assessment to the magistrate.
Dispute Centres on Remarks During 2025 Election Campaign
The defamation complaint arose from Singh’s remarks when he was the BJP candidate from Delhi’s Shakur Basti constituency. Jain alleged that the statements portrayed him as corrupt, dishonest and involved in the illegal accumulation of wealth. Singh’s defence, meanwhile, maintained that his statements drew upon information attributed to the ED and media reports and were made in the context of an election campaign.
The latest dismissal of Singh’s revision petition marks another development in the legal dispute over the alleged remarks. The allegations against Singh remain allegations in the defamation proceedings and are subject to adjudication in accordance with the law.

